Fact check: How true is Ambode’s claim that land use charge has not been reviewed in 15 years?

Fact check: How true is Ambode’s claim that land use charge has not been reviewed in 15 years?

The Lagos state house of assembly, on January 29, 2018, passed the land use charge bill which was subsequently signed into law by the governor of the state, Akinwunmi Ambode, on February 8.

According to the new law: “A property solely occupied by the owner for a residential purpose will be charged at a rate of 0.076% per annum. A property occupied by the owner and tenant(s) or third parties will be charged 0.256% per annum, while an investment property fully occupied by tenants or third party(ies) for revenue generation will be charged at 0.76% per annum."

In February, new rates of the charge were reportedly sent to Lagosians and they were expected to compile with the new law and pay accordingly.

Failure to do so reportedly attracted penalties such as a 25% increase if payment was not made between 45 and 75 days after notice; a 50% increase after 105 days; and a 100% increase if payment is made between 75 and 105 days.

READ ALSO: Fact check: How true is INEC’s claim that underage voting motion pictures are from Kenya, not Kano?

According to the law, a property shall be liable to enforcement if payment is not made after 135 days of notice.

However, after series of criticisms and condemnation by Lagosians, the government reportedly extended the period of implementation till April 14, 2018.

In a bid to justify the increase in land use charge, Ambode said the law had not been reviewed since 2001.

He said: “The law was made in 2001. It provides that every five years, we should review it and also find a way to increase. Fifteen years after in 2017, the law has never been reviewed.”

The Lagos state governor also said the rates were determined by the present value of properties which has “appreciated since the last review in 2001”.

“Now, the question is this: those who are having commercial properties, the rental income they were getting in 2002 as against the rental income they are getting in 2017, is it the same?” he asked.

“The level of infrastructure that existed in 2002 as against what has happened in the last 15 years, are they the same? Did it not come at a cost? So, why is the market value of the property that you built with one million naira, 15 years after, you are selling at N20 million? Why do you think somebody who is a buyer will pay N20million for it? Is it not because of the facilities around the property? So, we have to sacrifice; that is how it works everywhere.

“So, somebody comes and say we have increased by 400%. The question is the 400% of what? You were paying N10, 000 before, now we say you should pay N50, 000 and you are calculating and turning statistics upside down by saying it is 400%.”

The question, thus, is: is it true that Lagos land use charge has not been reviewed in 15 years as claimed by Governor Ambode.

Legit.ng provides the facts as checked by the Cable Newspaper.

According to checks by the Cable, the law has been reviewed three times. After the original bill was signed into law in 2001, it was reviewed by the administrations of Bola Tinubu and Babatunde Fashola, former governors of the state.

While Tinubu reviewed it in 2003, Fashola did so in 2008 and 2012.

This is contrary to Ambode’s claim that the law has never been reviewed.

Fact check: How true is Ambode’s claim that land use charge has not been reviewed in 15 years?

The public notice issued based after Tinubu considered the recommendation of a committee he set up to review the law. Source: The Cable

In 2003, Tinubu set up a special committee chaired by Lateef Okunnu, the renowned lawyer, to review the law.

At the end of its sitting, the committee published a communique. One of the recommendations was a downward review of the rates. In line with that, Lagos state cut the rates in 2003.

Fact check: How true is Ambode’s claim that land use charge has not been reviewed in 15 years?

A proof that the rates were reduced following the intervention of the committee. Source: The Cable

Commercial properties were then charged at 0.375%, residential property/commercial at 0.125%, industrial premises of manufacturing concerns at 0.125%, owner-occupied/residential property at 0.0375, owner-occupied pensioner property and family compound/public were also exempted.

The communique read in part: “In effect, all bills for 2002 have now been discounted by 75% or more depending on the class of property in question.

“That property owners, who by the virtue of recalculation of the rates for 2002, have overpaid their land use charge for 2002, a credit of overpayment will be made towards future land use charges.”

Provision (4) of the 2003 review reportedly warned that “the current valuations made under the land use charge law of No 11 0f 2001, shall not be unreasonably increased in future. All proposals for review shall be taken in conjunction with independent registered estate surveyors and valuers.”

PAY ATTENTION: Read the news on Nigeria’s #1 new app

Based on the above recommendation, the cable asserts that a strong argument can be made that the current administration disregarded the recommendation of the Okunnu committee.

In 2012, the administration of Fashola reportedly reviewed the charge to reflect an increase in all categories except pensioners, family compounds and religious properties.

As of the last review in 2012, commercial properties reportedly attracted a rate of 0.394%; a property solely occupied by the owner for residential purpose was charged at a rate of 0.0394%; while a similar property occupied by the property owner and tenant(s) or third parties will be charged at a rate of 0.132%. An investment property fully occupied by tenants or third party (ies) for revenue generation, was charged at a rate of 0.394%.”

The Cable reports that Governor Ambode has been accused of “force-feeding” Lagosians with the new law.

The state government reportedly did not make due consultations with the relevant stakeholders before initiating the increase in the charge.

The government also went ahead to demand implementation of the regulation same month it was passed, without prior notice to residents of the state.

It was only after much complaints and criticisms from the Lagosians that the government extended the grace period for defaulters.

Conclusion

In his reaction to the land use charge review controversy, Kehinde Bamigbetan, the Lagos state commissioner for information, told the Cable that the bill was repealed under the Ambode administration.

He admitted that the previous administrations reviewed the law, against Governor Ambode’s claim that the law has not been reviewed in 15 years.

He said: “What happened in 2012 is a review; what is happening now is a repeal. In 2012, parts of the law were reviewed but what is happening now is a total transformation of the law.”

Nevertheless, since Governor Ambode used the word review, not repeal, the claim of the governor is false.

It is incorrect to say the land use charge had never been reviewed since inception. Records prove otherwise.

According to an earlier report by Legit.ng, the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA), Ikeja branch today, Tuesday, March 13 commenced the much talked about protest against the reviewed land use charge law in Lagos state.

The NBA chairman, Adesina Ogunlana, lead members of the branch and others in the protest despite speculations that the protest may not hold.

Reported attempts by the Lagos state police commissioner to stop the protest failed. However, the police later agreed to provide security cover for the lawyers.

Ambode's second term is shaking, says Lagos woman - on Legit.ng TV

Source: Legit.ng

Mailfire view pixel